Life Expectancy Is More Than Living Longer
What’s more important to you: living longer or living better with the years you have? Think about it as you read this Memo and I’ll come back to that later.
The Upside of the Study
There were three important lifestyle variables that clearly stood out (1). The more exercise you get, the better off you are. Of those who got perfect 5s, they averaged over an hour per day of exercise. Second, the lower the BMI, the better; researchers didn’t track who might have lost weight over the years to get in the lowest BMI category, but it’s clear that carrying fewer pounds helps.
Finally, the Alternate Healthy Eating Index (AHEI) is a score of the quality of the diet, not the quantity. The highest quintile was below 60 out of 100 possible points. That means you don’t have to eat perfectly; just eat your vegetables and fruit and fewer refined carbohydrates and sugars, and you’ll see benefits.
The Downside of the Study
The subjects were overwhelmingly white and they were nurses and doctors for the most part. Whether that translates to other races and professions, we just don’t know.
The biggest issue for me is the Food Frequency Questionnaire used in the original studies as well as the AHEI scores. Trying to remember what you’ve eaten in so many categories over a year never made sense to me; there’s just too much potential for error. There were also differences in AHEI scores between the Nurses Study (all women) and the Health Professionals Follow-Up Study (all men). The men had an AHEI of 59 while the women in the nurses study had an AHEI of 37.5 in the groups assigned a 5. That makes no sense to me. I know the FFQ were slightly different, but the way the data are extracted to arrive at the AHEI score should have accounted for that. Are men so much better with the quality of their diet? Not buying it.
Supplements
Here’s something I found interesting. The use of a baby aspirin went up as the overall scores went up. In contrast, multivitamin use went up as the overall scores went down. To me, that means that healthcare professionals in all professions know that taking a baby aspirin is good for you. It also means that the poorer the diet, the more people try to compensate with supplements. The goal should be to complement a good diet with a multi, not try to make up for a poor one.
Amount of Time Living with Disease
I asked you a question at the beginning of this memo: what’s more important to you: living longer or living better? Right now, the average number of years spent living with some form of disease is almost 12 years (2). Not every condition is as debilitating as others, but would you rather live longer no matter what your health is or would you rather live well right up to the day you check out? Only you can answer that one. The study didn’t examine quality of life so we don’t know how the subjects did.
Here’s my guess: I would wager that the more healthy lifestyle variables you can add to your life, the longer and better you will live. Eat less. Eat better. Move more. It all starts with those six words.
What are you prepared to do today?
Dr. Chet
References:
1. https://doi.org/10.1161/CIRCULATIONAHA.117.032047.
2. https://ourworldindata.org/life-expectancy.
