Eggs: A Practical Solution
Based on Tuesday’s Memo, do we have a “hard-boiled” answer to the question of whether the dietary cholesterol in egg yolks positively impacts LDL-cholesterol levels? Or total cholesterol levels? We can’t “eggsactly” get a complete answer from this study, and here’s why. (Okay, no more puns or “yolking” around.)
Study Issues
- The LDL-cholesterol levels in the EGG phase (high cholesterol, low sat fat, two eggs per day) were 104 mg/dl. That was lower than the 108 mg/dl in the EGG-Free phase (low cholesterol, high sat fat, no eggs) and lower than the 109 mg/dl in the control group that ate the typical diet, but with only one egg per week. The standard deviation with the groups was over 20 mg/dl, which means that 66.7% of the subjects in any group could be 20 mg higher or 20 mg lower; that 104 result could actually be 84–124.
- While an argument could be made that the standard deviations were similar, there’s also the potential measurement error. That is currently 12%, so as all measures were about 100 mg/dl, each individual measurement could be within a range of 88–112 mg/dl.
These two issues alone raise doubt whether the EGG diet clearly reduced LDL-cholesterol.
There are also a couple of dietary factors:
- When placed on the reduced fat diet while eating two eggs per day, the fiber intake increased by eight grams per day, while the grams of protein decreased by 20–30 grams per day. Fiber can lower cholesterol.
- Less protein would be available to be made into sugar and fat.
One comment pointed to the statement “funded by the Egg Council” to suggest that’s why the data skewed the way it did, but the last thing we want to do is discourage that kind of research. If private companies and associations do not fund research, it won’t get done; there’s no reason to believe that the NIH will fund basic science research going forward.
A Practical Approach
As I’ve maintained recently, whether talking about seed oils, maltodextrin, or eggs in this case, it’s all about the amount consumed. What the study did show is that excess saturated fat may be, and probably always has been, the cause of abnormal cholesterol levels in people without the genetic tendency toward high cholesterol. The lesson for us is to try to get saturated fat intake to less than 10% of your total caloric intake. One more thing—increase the intake of vegetables to decrease the percentage of saturated fat as well.
If you follow these two suggestions, there should be no problem with eating eggs every day if you want. Just be careful of fat bombs such as sausage and bacon that can add fat you don’t need.
What are you prepared to do today?
Dr. Chet
Reference: AJCN. 2025. 122 :83–91. DOI: 10.1016/j.ajcnut.2025.05.001
